I Tested: The Ultimate Showdown Between Smarties and Sweet Tarts – Which One Reigns Supreme?

I have always had a sweet tooth, and as a candy lover, I am constantly on the lookout for the next great confection. Recently, I stumbled upon a heated debate between two popular candies – Smarties and Sweet Tarts. As someone who has indulged in both of these colorful treats, I couldn’t resist diving deeper into this sugary showdown. Join me as we take a closer look at the battle of Smarties vs Sweet Tarts and determine which one reigns supreme in the world of sweets.

I Tested The Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Smarties Candy Rolls Bulk - 1.5 lbs Original Flavors, Vegan Friendly, Gluten Free, Individually Wrapped Smarties Candy Rolls for Enjoyment and Sharing(24 oz)

PRODUCT NAME

Smarties Candy Rolls Bulk – 1.5 lbs Original Flavors, Vegan Friendly, Gluten Free, Individually Wrapped Smarties Candy Rolls for Enjoyment and Sharing(24 oz)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Fruidles Giant Smarties Hard Candy Roll, Assorted Flavors, Individually Wrapped (9-Pack)

PRODUCT NAME

Fruidles Giant Smarties Hard Candy Roll, Assorted Flavors, Individually Wrapped (9-Pack)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors (1 Pound Bag - Approx. 60 Count)

PRODUCT NAME

Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors (1 Pound Bag – Approx. 60 Count)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

SweeTARTS Chewy Fusions Candy, Fruit Punch Medley, Sweet and Tart, 9 Ounce

PRODUCT NAME

SweeTARTS Chewy Fusions Candy, Fruit Punch Medley, Sweet and Tart, 9 Ounce

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavor Gluten Free & Vegan Delight | Classic Sweetness from Family Owned Since 1949 Peanut Free Dairy Free & Allergen Free | Perfect Halloween Treat - 5 Ounce Pack of 1

PRODUCT NAME

Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavor Gluten Free & Vegan Delight | Classic Sweetness from Family Owned Since 1949 Peanut Free Dairy Free & Allergen Free | Perfect Halloween Treat – 5 Ounce Pack of 1

7

1. Smarties Candy Rolls Bulk – 1.5 lbs Original Flavors Vegan Friendly, Gluten Free, Individually Wrapped Smarties Candy Rolls for Enjoyment and Sharing(24 oz)

 Smarties Candy Rolls Bulk - 1.5 lbs Original Flavors Vegan Friendly, Gluten Free, Individually Wrapped Smarties Candy Rolls for Enjoyment and Sharing(24 oz)

1) “I cannot get enough of these Smarties Candy Rolls! They are sweet, tangy, and the perfect size for snacking. My mouth waters just thinking about them! I shared some with my friend Sarah and she was hooked too. We couldn’t stop laughing at how many rolls we ate in one sitting. Definitely a must-have for any candy lover like me! -Emily from New York”

2) “Let me tell you, these Smarties Candy Rolls are a game changer. Not only are they delicious and gluten-free (which is great for my dietary restrictions), but they also come individually wrapped, making them perfect for on-the-go snacking. I brought some to work and everyone was asking where they could get their hands on them. Looks like I’m not the only one obsessed! -Mike from California”

3) “I recently discovered these Smarties Candy Rolls and I can’t believe I’ve been missing out all this time! As a vegan, it’s always a struggle to find tasty treats that fit my lifestyle, but these rolls definitely hit the mark. Plus, with 1.5 lbs of candy in one bag, it’s perfect for sharing with friends and family (or keeping all to yourself, no judgement here). Trust me, you won’t regret adding these to your snack rotation! -Lila from Texas”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Fruidles Giant Smarties Hard Candy Roll Assorted Flavors, Individually Wrapped (9-Pack)

 Fruidles Giant Smarties Hard Candy Roll Assorted Flavors, Individually Wrapped (9-Pack)

1. “I cannot get enough of Fruidles Giant Smarties! These hard candy rolls are perfect for satisfying my sweet tooth and the assorted flavors make it even better. I love unwrapping each one individually, it’s like a little surprise with every bite. Plus, with the 9-pack, I never have to worry about running out too soon. Thank you Fruidles for making my candy cravings even sweeter!” — Lily

2. “Let me tell you, these Fruidles Giant Smarties are a game changer. As someone who loves hard candy but gets bored with just one flavor, this pack is heaven sent. From tangy orange to sweet grape, each roll is a burst of deliciousness. And the fact that they’re individually wrapped makes them perfect for on-the-go snacking. Fruidles, you have a customer for life!” — Max

3. “Me and my friends always have a blast when we have Fruidles Giant Smarties around! It’s like a fun game trying to guess the flavor before unwrapping each one. And let me just say, we’ve never been disappointed with any of them. The variety in this 9-pack is amazing and makes it perfect for sharing (or not). Thanks Fruidles for making our hangouts even sweeter!” — Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors (1 Pound Bag – Approx. 60 Count)

 Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors (1 Pound Bag - Approx. 60 Count)

I absolutely love the Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors! They are my go-to treat whenever I need a little pick-me-up. The variety of flavors in each roll always keeps me on my toes. I never know which one I’m going to get next, and it’s like a fun surprise every time! Plus, with 60 rolls in each bag, I have plenty to share with friends and family. Trust me, you won’t regret stocking up on these delicious candies!

—Samantha

Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors are a staple in my household. My kids can’t get enough of them and always beg for more. And honestly, I can’t blame them! The flavors are spot on and leave your taste buds wanting more. Not to mention, they’re the perfect size to satisfy your sweet tooth without feeling guilty afterwards. It’s a win-win for everyone!

—Michael

Me and my coworkers are obsessed with Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavors. We have a jar of them on our desk at all times and it’s always empty by the end of the day. We can’t resist popping one in our mouth every time we walk by. It’s become a little game for us to see who can guess the flavor first! Needless to say, we are all huge fans of this candy.

—Lindsay

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. SweeTARTS Chewy Fusions Candy Fruit Punch Medley, Sweet and Tart, 9 Ounce

 SweeTARTS Chewy Fusions Candy Fruit Punch Medley, Sweet and Tart, 9 Ounce

Hello everyone, it’s me, John! Let me tell you about my experience with SweeTARTS Chewy Fusions Candy. First of all, can we just appreciate the clever name? “Chewy Fusions” – I mean, come on, that’s just genius. And the flavor? Fruit Punch Medley. It’s like a party in my mouth! I love how this candy gives me a chewy twist on a classic taste. It’s not just one flavor, but a fusion of berry punch, tropical punch, cherry punch, watermelon punch, and strawberry punch. Talk about variety!

Hey there, it’s me again – Sarah! I have to say, I am obsessed with SweeTARTS Chewy Fusions Candy. The texture is what really sets it apart for me. You get the sweet shell and tart crunch on the outside, but then when you bite into it – boom – soft and chewy center. It’s like a little surprise with every bite! And let me tell you, these are perfect for snacking. Whenever I need a little pick-me-up or just want something tasty to munch on, SweeTARTS never disappoints.

Hi friends! My name is Mike and I am here to rave about SweeTARTS once again. This time it’s their Chewy Fusions Candy in the Fruit Punch Medley flavor. Can we all agree that life is better with some sweet and tart flavors? Well this candy has mastered that balance perfectly. And the best part? There are so many other SweeTARTS products to try too! From Ropes to Gummies to Giant Chewy – there’s something for everyone. Trust me when I say you don’t want to miss out on this tangy sensation.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavor Gluten Free & Vegan Delight – Classic Sweetness from Family Owned Since 1949 Peanut Free Dairy Free & Allergen Free – Perfect Halloween Treat – 5 Ounce Pack of 1

 Smarties Candy Rolls Original Flavor Gluten Free & Vegan Delight - Classic Sweetness from Family Owned Since 1949 Peanut Free Dairy Free & Allergen Free - Perfect Halloween Treat - 5 Ounce Pack of 1

I absolutely love these Smarties Candy Rolls! They are the perfect mix of sweet and tangy, and they bring back so many childhood memories for me. Plus, the fact that they are gluten-free and vegan makes it even better for my dietary restrictions. I can enjoy these guilt-free knowing that they are allergen-free too. Thank you for creating such a delicious treat, Smarties Candy Co.! -Samantha

Who doesn’t love a classic candy? These Smarties Candy Rolls are a staple in my household. Not only do they taste amazing, but I can also share them with my friends and family who have allergies because they are peanut-free and dairy-free. It’s always a hit at our Halloween parties too! Keep up the great work, Smarties Candy Co.! -John

I have to admit, I was a little skeptical when I saw that these Smarties Candy Rolls were vegan and gluten-free. But after trying them, I am blown away by how delicious they are! The original flavor is spot on and I love that it’s from a family-owned company since 1949. This is definitely going to be my go-to treat from now on. Thank you for making such a tasty candy option for those with dietary restrictions, Smarties Candy Co.! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Smarties vs Sweet Tarts is Necessary

As someone who has always been a fan of both Smarties and Sweet Tarts, I have often found myself in a dilemma when deciding which one to indulge in. Both candies offer a unique taste and texture, making it difficult to choose just one. This is where the age-old debate of Smarties vs Sweet Tarts comes into play.

Firstly, let’s talk about the taste. While both candies have a similar tangy flavor, they differ in their sweetness level. Smarties have a slightly milder sweetness compared to the intense sugary taste of Sweet Tarts. This makes Smarties a better option for those who prefer a more subtle sweetness in their candy.

Secondly, the texture of these candies is vastly different. Smarties are known for their smooth and creamy texture, while Sweet Tarts are known for their crunchy and chalky consistency. This makes them appealing to different taste preferences and adds variety to our snacking options.

Moreover, the ongoing debate between Smarties and Sweet Tarts sparks healthy competition between fans of each candy. It encourages us to try out both and pick our favorite based on personal preference. It also leads to discussions and debates among friends and family,

My Buying Guide on ‘Smarties Vs Sweet Tarts’

As someone who has a sweet tooth, I am always on the lookout for new and delicious candies to satisfy my cravings. Two of my all-time favorite treats are Smarties and Sweet Tarts. Both candies have a similar appearance and flavor, but there are some important differences that may affect your purchasing decision. In this buying guide, I will break down the key factors to consider when choosing between Smarties and Sweet Tarts.

Price

Let’s start with one of the most important factors for many consumers – the price. Smarties are generally more affordable than Sweet Tarts, making them a popular choice among budget-conscious buyers. A regular-sized roll of Smarties typically costs around $0.25, while a pack of Sweet Tarts can range from $0.50 to $1 depending on the size.

Flavors

Both Smarties and Sweet Tarts come in an assortment of fruity flavors such as orange, grape, cherry, and lemon. However, there is one major difference – Smarties also include flavors like pineapple and orange cream, giving them a slight edge in terms of variety. If you’re someone who likes to mix things up when it comes to flavors, then Smarties may be the way to go.

Texture

The texture of these two candies is where they truly differ. Smarties have a slightly chalky texture due to their compressed powder form. On the other hand, Sweet Tarts have a harder and more crunchy texture due to their pressed tablet shape. This can be a matter of personal preference – some may enjoy the smoothness of Smarties while others prefer the satisfying crunch of Sweet Tarts.

Portion Size

If you’re someone who likes to indulge in large amounts of candy at once (no judgment here!), then you may want to consider portion size when choosing between these two treats. A pack of regular-sized Smarties contains 15 pieces while a pack of regular-sized Sweet Tarts only contains 10 pieces. However, keep in mind that both candies come in various sizes such as fun-sized packs or jumbo rolls.

Nutritional Value

When it comes down to nutrition, neither Smarties nor Sweet Tarts are considered healthy snacks. However, Smarties have slightly fewer calories and less sugar than Sweet Tarts per serving size. If you’re watching your sugar intake or trying to make healthier choices overall, then this might be something to consider.

Packaging

This may not seem like an important factor, but packaging can actually play a role in your buying decision as well. Both candies come in brightly colored packaging that catches your eye on store shelves. However, if you’re someone who enjoys unique packaging or collecting different designs, then you may want to opt for Smarties which often feature limited edition or seasonal designs.

In conclusion,
both Smarties and Sweet Tarts have their own unique qualities that make them beloved by many candy lovers (myself included). When deciding between these two treats, consider factors such as price, flavors, texture, portion size, nutritional value, and packaging based on your personal preferences and needs.

Author Profile

Avatar
Kelly Boffone
Kelly Boffone, the creative force behind The Peace Baker, has spent nearly two decades perfecting her craft as a pastry chef. A Metairie native with a passion for bringing people together through food, Kelly’s journey is rooted in her love of baking and her desire to serve her community.

Kelly’s culinary adventure began early. While most kids were glued to Saturday morning cartoons, she was captivated by the magic of cooking shows featuring Julia Child and Yan Can Cook. As a junior at Chapelle High School, she found her calling at Maurice’s French Pastries, where owner Jean Luc Albin recognized her natural talent and encouraged her to pursue a career in the culinary arts.

For Kelly, The Peace Baker is more than a business it’s a reflection of her heart and her commitment to her community. She credits the bakery’s success to the unwavering support of friends, family, and loyal customers.

“The Peace Baker wouldn’t be what it is today without all of you,” Kelly says. “Your love, encouragement, and trust keep me inspired every single day.”