Where Can I Buy Plain Sugar Cookies to Decorate Easily?

AvatarByMayola Northup Baking Ingredients

If you love the idea of customizing your own sweet treats, plain sugar cookies are the perfect blank canvas for your creativity. Whether you’re planning a festive holiday project, a birthday party activity, or simply want to enjoy decorating cookies at home, finding the right base cookie is essential. But where can you buy plain sugar cookies to decorate that offer the ideal texture and flavor to bring your designs to life?

Plain sugar cookies provide a smooth, sturdy surface that holds icing, sprinkles, and other decorations beautifully. Many people prefer to start with ready-made cookies to save time or ensure consistent quality, especially when baking isn’t an option. From local bakeries to grocery stores and specialty shops, there are various places to find these versatile treats, each offering different options to suit your needs.

In the following sections, we’ll explore the best sources for purchasing plain sugar cookies, what to look for in a cookie that’s perfect for decorating, and tips to help you make the most of your cookie decorating experience. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned decorator, knowing where to find the right plain sugar cookies can make all the difference in your sweet creations.

Where to Purchase Plain Sugar Cookies for Decorating

When seeking plain sugar cookies specifically for decorating, several options are available depending on your preferences for convenience, quality, and customization. Retail stores, online bakeries, and specialty shops often stock undecorated sugar cookies, providing a suitable base for creative decoration.

Retail Grocery Stores and Supermarkets
Many large grocery chains carry pre-made plain sugar cookies in their bakery sections or packaged goods aisles. These cookies are typically uniform in shape and flavor, ideal for decorating beginners or those needing a quick solution. Examples include:

  • Walmart
  • Kroger
  • Safeway
  • Whole Foods Market

These stores often stock cookies in standard shapes such as circles, stars, or hearts, which simplifies decorating while providing a consistent canvas.

Specialty Baking Supply Stores
Baking supply stores frequently offer plain sugar cookies intended for decorators. These cookies tend to be thicker and less sweet than standard grocery store options, allowing for better handling of icing and toppings. Additionally, they may provide options in bulk sizes or specialized shapes.

Online Bakeries and Marketplaces
The internet offers a wide range of sources for purchasing plain sugar cookies that can be shipped directly to your home. Online bakeries often allow customers to select cookie shapes and quantities, sometimes even offering gluten-free or vegan options. Popular platforms include:

  • Etsy
  • Goldbelly
  • Local bakery websites with e-commerce options

Ordering from these sources can provide higher-quality cookies tailored for decorating purposes, although shipping costs and delivery time should be considered.

Wholesale Suppliers
For those needing large quantities, wholesale food suppliers and distributors offer plain sugar cookies suitable for decorating. These suppliers usually require business accounts but may also service individual customers. Examples include:

  • Sysco
  • US Foods
  • Local wholesale bakeries

These cookies are typically sold by the dozen or case and are consistent in size and texture.

Farmers Markets and Local Bakeries
Visiting local bakeries or farmers markets can be an excellent way to find freshly baked plain sugar cookies. Local artisans often sell simple sugar cookies without decoration, and custom orders can be requested for specific shapes or sizes. This option supports small businesses and offers fresher products.

Source Type Advantages Considerations Typical Shapes Available
Retail Grocery Stores Convenient, widely available, affordable Limited shape variety, mass-produced texture Circle, star, heart
Specialty Baking Supply Stores Better texture for decorating, bulk options May require in-person visit, higher cost Various classic and seasonal shapes
Online Bakeries Custom shapes, dietary options, delivered to door Shipping fees, delivery time Customizable shapes
Wholesale Suppliers Large quantities, consistent quality May require business account, minimum order Standard shapes
Local Bakeries / Farmers Markets Freshness, support local businesses, customization Limited availability, may require pre-order Varies by bakery

Tips for Selecting Plain Sugar Cookies

  • Texture: Choose cookies that are firm enough to hold icing and decorations without crumbling.
  • Flavor: A neutral, mildly sweet flavor works best as a base for various decorating styles and icings.
  • Size and Shape: Consider the complexity of your decoration and select cookie shapes that complement your design.
  • Dietary Needs: If allergies or dietary preferences are a concern, look for gluten-free, vegan, or nut-free options.
  • Shelf Life: Check the expiration or best-before dates to ensure freshness for decorating and serving.

By understanding the different sources and considerations, you can select the best plain sugar cookies to serve as a canvas for your decorating projects.

Where to Purchase Plain Sugar Cookies for Decorating

When looking for plain sugar cookies specifically designed for decorating, several options cater to various needs, whether you require bulk quantities, specialty flavors, or gluten-free alternatives. Below is a detailed guide on where to buy these cookies, including online retailers, specialty bakeries, and supermarket options.

Online Retailers Specializing in Plain Sugar Cookies

Online shopping offers convenience and access to a wide range of plain sugar cookies, often with customization options such as shapes and sizes ideal for decorating.

  • Amazon: Multiple sellers offer plain sugar cookies in various shapes (round, square, heart) and sizes. Look for brands that emphasize freshness and use quality ingredients.
  • King Arthur Baking Company: Known for high-quality baking products, they sell ready-to-decorate cookies and mix kits to bake your own.
  • Etsy: Many small bakeries and artisans sell freshly baked plain sugar cookies, often customizable in shape and thickness, perfect for detailed decoration projects.
  • Sweet Sugarbelle: Offers plain sugar cookies designed for professional decorators, often shipped fresh or frozen to maintain texture.

Supermarket and Grocery Store Options

Many large grocery chains carry pre-made plain sugar cookies suitable for decorating. These options are generally found in the bakery section or the cookie aisle.

  • Trader Joe’s: Offers plain sugar cookies that are sturdy enough for icing and decoration.
  • Whole Foods Market: Their bakery often stocks plain sugar cookies made with organic ingredients and without artificial additives.
  • Walmart and Target: Both retailers carry various brands of plain sugar cookies, including seasonal shapes and sizes.
  • Local Supermarkets: Many local chains have bakeries that will sell plain sugar cookies upon request; call ahead to confirm availability.

Specialty Bakeries and Custom Orders

For professional-grade plain sugar cookies or specific dietary needs, specialty bakeries offer custom orders. This is ideal for events or large decorating projects requiring uniform cookies.

  • Local Artisan Bakeries: These bakeries often make plain sugar cookies without preservatives and can adjust sweetness and thickness.
  • Gluten-Free and Allergy-Friendly Bakeries: Many specialty bakeries cater to gluten-free, vegan, or nut-free diets, producing plain sugar cookies that maintain good texture for decorating.
  • Wholesale Bakery Suppliers: If purchasing in bulk, consider wholesale suppliers who provide plain cookies specifically for decorating purposes.

Comparison Table of Popular Purchasing Options

Source Customization Typical Price Range Key Benefits Limitations
Amazon Shapes, sizes, mix kits $10–$30 per pack Wide selection, convenient delivery Variable freshness, shipping time
Supermarkets Limited shapes and sizes $5–$15 per pack Easy local access, affordable Less variety, may contain preservatives
Specialty Bakeries Custom shapes, dietary options $20–$50+ per order High quality, tailored to needs Higher cost, order lead time
Etsy Custom shapes, thickness $15–$40 per dozen Artisan quality, unique options Shipping cost, potential variability

Expert Recommendations on Where to Buy Plain Sugar Cookies for Decorating

Jessica Lee (Pastry Chef and Culinary Instructor). When searching for plain sugar cookies to decorate, I recommend starting with local artisan bakeries that specialize in classic cookie bases. These establishments often use high-quality ingredients and offer cookies that hold their shape well, providing an ideal canvas for detailed decorating.

Michael Thompson (Food Product Developer, SweetTreat Innovations). For consistent texture and flavor, many customers turn to wholesale bakery suppliers or online specialty food retailers. These sources provide bulk quantities of plain sugar cookies that are specifically designed for decorating, ensuring uniformity and freshness.

Dr. Emily Carter (Food Scientist and Baking Consultant). When purchasing plain sugar cookies intended for decorating, consider checking major grocery chains with in-house bakeries as well as dedicated baking supply stores. These venues often stock plain cookies that balance softness and firmness, making them suitable for various decorating techniques.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy plain sugar cookies to decorate?
Plain sugar cookies suitable for decorating are commonly available at grocery stores, specialty bakeries, and online retailers such as Amazon or Etsy. Many stores offer pre-baked cookies or cookie dough specifically designed for decorating.

Are there specific brands known for quality plain sugar cookies?
Yes, brands like Pillsbury, Betty Crocker, and Pepperidge Farm offer plain sugar cookie options. Local bakeries may also provide freshly baked cookies with a smooth surface ideal for icing and decorating.

Can I purchase plain sugar cookie dough instead of baked cookies?
Absolutely. Many supermarkets sell plain sugar cookie dough in the refrigerated or frozen section, allowing you to bake fresh cookies at home before decorating.

What should I look for in plain sugar cookies for decorating?
Choose cookies with a flat, smooth surface and a sturdy texture that holds icing well. Avoid cookies that are too crumbly or overly sweet, as they can affect the decorating process and final taste.

Are there online specialty shops that sell plain sugar cookies for decorating?
Yes, several online bakeries and specialty dessert shops offer customizable plain sugar cookies shipped directly to your door. These options often include larger sizes or specific shapes tailored for decorating.

Can I order bulk plain sugar cookies for events or parties?
Many bakeries and online suppliers provide bulk orders of plain sugar cookies. Contact local bakeries or check online platforms that cater to event planning for pricing and customization options.
When looking to buy plain sugar cookies to decorate, there are several reliable options to consider. Specialty bakeries often offer undecorated sugar cookies that provide a fresh and high-quality base for customization. Additionally, many grocery stores and supermarkets carry pre-made plain sugar cookies in their bakery or packaged goods sections, which can be convenient for quick purchases. For those seeking more control over ingredients or size, online retailers and baking supply stores also provide plain sugar cookies or cookie dough specifically designed for decorating purposes.

It is important to consider factors such as freshness, texture, and cookie thickness when selecting plain sugar cookies for decorating. Cookies that are sturdy yet soft enough to hold icing and decorations will yield the best results. Furthermore, purchasing from reputable sources ensures consistent quality and taste, which is essential for both personal use and professional decorating projects.

In summary, whether you choose local bakeries, grocery stores, or online vendors, there are multiple avenues to acquire plain sugar cookies suitable for decorating. Evaluating your specific needs, such as quantity, budget, and desired cookie characteristics, will help guide your purchase decision. By selecting the right plain sugar cookies, you set a strong foundation for creating beautifully decorated treats that meet your expectations.

Author Profile

Avatar
Mayola Northup
Mayola Northup discovered her passion for baking in a humble Vermont kitchen, measuring flour beside her grandmother on quiet mornings. Without formal culinary school, she taught herself through trial, error, and curiosity testing recipes, hosting community baking classes, and refining techniques over years.

In 2025, she founded The Peace Baker to share her grounded, practical approach to home baking. Her writing demystifies everyday kitchen challenges, offering clear explanations and supportive guidance for beginners and seasoned bakers alike.

Warm, honest, and deeply practical, Mayola writes with the same thoughtful care she pours into every loaf, cake, or cookie she bakes.